How Does Opening a New Credit Card Affect Your Scores?

You’ve probably heard it said that applying for a new credit card can have some negative effects on your scores. In addition to the “hard pull” credit inquiry that will likely result in a small score penalty, the age of your credit can be dragged down by a new account. Well, this week, I got to see first hand how temporary these minor hits can be and how opening a new card really impacts your credit score.

Before I get into it, I need to make clear that these are just my personal experiences — as they say, your mileage may vary. With that disclaimer out of the way, let me explain exactly how my credit cards were affected by my new credit card.

Last Thursday, I ended up applying and getting approved for the Uber Visa. When that happened,  my Transunion score dropped by six points according to Credit Karma. That dip was to be expected but what surprised me was what happened next.

While Barclay only pulled my Transunion report to make their decision, they reported my new account to all three major bureaus. Once this happened, my TransUnion score not only rebounded but exceeded what it was before and my other scores saw decent bumps as well. In fact, Barclay quoted my FICO at 800 in their first update to me, but that rose to 811 in their next update. The reason for this has to do with how different credit factors are weighed under the credit system.

Although credit inquiries and age of credit do affect your scores, these only represent  10% and 15% of your score respectively. Meanwhile, my credit utilization — which makes up 30% of your score — decreased overall since I now have a few thousand extra dollars in available credit. So, while my scores may dip a bit when I actually start using my card (the current $0 balance is boosting my utilization), it seems I may come out ahead on this one.

The moral of the story is, because of how your credit scores are calculated and the factors that go into them, applying for a new credit card may not affect your credit scores the way you’re expecting. If my experience is anything to go by, you may see a small dip to begin with but see benefits overall. The key is just to continue to your good credit habits with your new card, including making timely payments and keeping your utilization low.

Author

Kyle Burbank

Kyle is a freelance writer and author whose first book, "The E-Ticket Life" is now available on Amazon. In addition to his weekly "Money at 30" column on Dyer News, he is also the editorial director and a writer for the Disney fan site LaughingPlace.com and the founder of Money@30.com.

Other Articles by Kyle Burbank

Starbucks Summer Game

Starbucks' Summer Game is Back and You Could Score Free Stars

I feel as though I'm kind of going back to my roots with this week's Quick Tip: discussing a new Starbucks promotion. If you're newer to my site, pre-pandemic, my wife and I would go to Starbucks every weekend as a means of hanging out with our favorite baristas, enjoying...
illustration of a sad woman starring at a wall

Cutting Your Loses: My Brokerage Battle and How I Finally Fixed It

Late last year, word came down that the app Bumped — which allowed customers to earn stock in the companies they made purchases from — was shutting down. As bummed as I was at the time, it turns out that this announcement would only be the start of my troubles....
Sapphire Lounge entrance

Travel Tuesday: Understanding Chase's New Sapphire Lounge

When Chase announced that it was opening a number of airport lounges in partnership with The Club, there were several questions I and others had. At the top of the list, with The Club being a staple of Priority Pass membership, it seemed fair to assume that those with Priority...
The "Email" field is empty, you must enter some text to proceed.The text you entered in the "Email" field appears to be invalid, please edit it and try again
Get Posts in Your Inbox
Featured Articles
Starbucks Summer Game

Starbucks' Summer Game is Back and You Could Score Free Stars

I feel as though I'm kind of going back to my roots with this week's Quick Tip: discussing a new Starbucks promotion. If you're newer to my site, pre-pandemic, my wife and I would go to Starbucks every weekend as a means of hanging out with our favorite baristas, enjoying...
illustration of a sad woman starring at a wall

Cutting Your Loses: My Brokerage Battle and How I Finally Fixed It

Late last year, word came down that the app Bumped — which allowed customers to earn stock in the companies they made purchases from — was shutting down. As bummed as I was at the time, it turns out that this announcement would only be the start of my troubles....
Sapphire Lounge entrance

Travel Tuesday: Understanding Chase's New Sapphire Lounge

When Chase announced that it was opening a number of airport lounges in partnership with The Club, there were several questions I and others had. At the top of the list, with The Club being a staple of Priority Pass membership, it seemed fair to assume that those with Priority...
TD Clear Visa Card

TD Bank Has a Pretty Dumb New Idea for a Credit Card Product

Doing what I do, I've seen several new credit card products come down the pike in recent years. Some of these are fairly boring (like 2% flat rate cards — they have a use but they're not exciting), others as more interesting but not for me (see: Ness Card), and...